Text and Dialogue
Balloons:
In Naruto, two different types of balloons were used to express different types of dialogue, while there was only one type of speech balloon used. In Naruto when a character was speaking regularly, their speech appeared in a circular balloon, but when a character was expressing any sort of excitement their speech appeared in a more jagged balloon. In Pinocchio, circular balloons were used when characters were speaking. A major difference is the narration for Pinocchio appeared in rectangular boxes.
Captions:
There was little to no captions used in Naruto, but in Pinocchio captions were a very important element. The captions that were used served as narration to the story.
Emanata:
In both of these texts, emanata were used in the same ways. There were lines that were used to indicate actions. Also smoke and clouds were used to create a dream/magical element in the novels.
Labels and Signs:
Labels and signs were not used a lot throughout either of these stories. In Naruto, there were a couple of signs with Japanese lettering and in Pinocchio there were signs that identified landmarks.
Lettering:
The lettering in Naruto reflect the actions and emotions that are taking place in the story. Different lettering and font sizes are used to show anger, fear, etc. In Pinocchio, the lettering stays the same throughout the story and are not of significance.
Sound Effects:
Pinocchio does not have any sound effects, but Naruto uses a lot of sound effects, especially in fighting scenes.
Visual Effects
Characters:
The characters in Pinocchio are not very detailed in illustrations. The characters are simply used to show emotion on their face. In Naruto, the characters are very detailed and they all have their own characteristics.
Objects:
The illustrations in Naruto are very detailed and it is also shown when looking at the objects of the novel. In Pinocchio, objects are rarely even seen and even if they were based on the illustrations, they would not be very detailed.
Icons:
The main icon in Pinocchio is most obvious, his nose. Whenever he lies, his nose grows, but it is used to help him when he fights. In Naruto, the main icon is the headband. The headband is something that he has been working for and once he gets it, it is looked at as an accomplishment of power.
Scenery:
The scenery in Naruto is very detailed and it adds to the story. The scenery is what makes the story realistic when it comes to the layout of the city. In Pinocchio, the scenery is not really illustrated, the illustrations of the story revolve around the actions of the characters.
Depicted Action:
In both of the stories, the actions revolve around fighting. In Pinocchio, most of the actions were fights with the vampires. In Naruto, the actions illustrated fights and also the thoughts of characters.
Borders:
Borders are used beautifully in both of the texts with very little variation.
Gutters:
The gutters in Naruto are always there, but the gutters in Pinocchio are only used sometimes. In both stories the only colors that are used for the gutters are black and white.
Panels:
The panels that were used in both of the texts varied in size depending on the action that was taking place in it.
Open Panels:
Both of the texts utilized open panels and it added to the amazing illustrations of the books. It appealed to the reader in a different way and spoke volumes. In both texts, open panels seemed to be used when a climatic action was taking place.
Splash:
Naruto did not have many splashes like Pinocchio. Pinocchio had a lot of action scenes when fights were occurring,
Angles and Frames
Bleed:
Both of these texts bleed. In Naruto, panels bleed onto other pages a lot. In Pinocchio, the bleeds are typically only onto other panels and not pages.
Close-up:
Close-ups are used a lot throughout Pinocchio and it adds to the drama of the story. Also in Naruto, close-ups of characters added the emotion of the story.
Head shot:
The headshotss of Pinocchio were used to show the emotions that were depicted on the characters faces. In Naruto, this novel utilized thought balloons, so close-ups were used for characters when they were thinking and the story was focused primarily on them.
Head-Shoulder Shot:
Head-Shoulder Shots were used in both texts and for the same reason, to better depict and illustrate the emotions that were taking place.
Full-Figure Shot:
Full-Figure shots were used in both the texts and it was primarily for when there was an action taking place and when there were multiple characters in a frame.
Long shot:
Both of the texts used long shots to show scenery as a background for the plot of the story. In Pinocchio, were he was fighting with vampires, long shots were used to show the actions.
Extreme Long shot:
Extreme Long shots were used primarily in Naruto when characters were conversing and there was a lot of scenery. Pinocchio did not utilize extreme long shots.
Reverse:
Reverse shots were used a lot throughout both of the texts and in the same way. We saw reverse shots used when characters were speaking back and forth to each other.
Rhetorical Techniques applied in Text, Visuals and Design
Exaggeration:
Both of these texts are tremendously exaggerated. Pinocchio was exaggerated when it came to scenery and the illustrations of death of the vampires. Naruto was exaggerated when it came to actions and emotions of the main characters.
Empathy/Identification:
Other than Pinocchio's father being dead, I could not identify with is character or the things he went through; therefore, I did not feel much empathy. The characters in Naruto were easier to identify with because they had emotions and trials that are a bit more relatable.
Mood/Tone:
The mood and tone of both of these books are extremely different. Pinocchio is really dark and contemptuous. Naruto has a lighter tone and is inclusive to comedy.
Simplicity/Complexity:
Pinocchio based on organization was quite simplistic, but the storyline could be complex at times. Naruto was a bit more complex because of its writing format. Unless a person truly knows how to read this type of graphic novel, it will be hard to follow because it goes against the way we know how the read, left to right, front to back.
Irony/Satire:
Naruto's power is very ironic. He is basically hated by the townspeople and no one at school really likes him, yet he is the most powerful person around. In Pinocchio, there is so much irony and satire. The children's story Pinocchio sets the foundation of this story, but his lies are used for the betterment of society.
Realism/Icons/Symbols:
At times I lack an imagination because things seem to not be in the least bit real. Both of these stories lacked realism, but I do not necessarily think this is a bad thing. The nose in Pinocchio definitely was not realistic, but at the same time it was symbolic. It is something that a young adult can identify with and they already have basic knowledge.
Order/Disorder:
There is a major difference between these two novels when it comes to order and disorder. In Naruto, there is not a lot of order and there is a lot going on throughout the novel. Part of this may be the type of graphic novel it is, manga. In Pinocchio, everything was in order. It was really easy to follow along and the text/illustrations were not difficult.
Juxtaposition:
Naruto and Pinocchio seem to share the same juxtaposition throughout both of the graphic novels, which is good vs. evil. This juxtaposition is presented differently in each novel, but it is still prevalent. In Pinocchio, he is fighting vampires. In every fight there is always a good and evil side. In Naruto, his personality and mannerism reflects this idea. He has a good and evil side that is observed throughout the novel.
Relationships:
Naruto does not have that many characters, but all of the characters are interconnected. Naruto seems to be hated and he does not have many good relationships with the other characters his age in the novel, his closest relationship is with a teacher. In Pinocchio, the trend continues. There are not a lot of relationships throughout the novel and the person closest to Pinocchio, his father, is no longer living.
Point of View:
Naruto is not told from one specific point of view, but it is in third person. Pinocchio utilizes a narrator to tell the story and throughout the graphic novel, the reader is able to feel the narrator's emotion through his/her narration.